Introduction
to Tales from the Crypt of Cthulhu

Issue 016

copyright © 1983 by Robert M. Price
reprinted by permission of Robert M. Price

Welcome, fear-fans, to this ichor-curdling collection of rancid recitals from R'lyeh called . . . heh-heh . . . Tales from the Crypt of Cthulhu! But before you dig into this foetid fright-feast, let your old Crypt-of-Cthulhu-Keeper share a few words about what's in store. . . .

Just when it seems that the literary remains of a writer have been picked clean, further ghoulish digging is sometimes rewarded with big surprises. It is from such unsuspected recesses that we bring you the current collection of neglected fiction by the masters of the Weird Tales tradition.

"The Tree on the Hill" first appeared in the September 1940 issue of Polaris, a small-circulation mimeographed fanzine. There it was credited to Duane W. Rimel, who did indeed write the initial draft, which became the initial portion of the finished story. He passed the draft onto his friend H. P. Lovecraft who had performed revisory services on Rimel's earlier tale "The Sorcery of Aphlar". "The Tree on the Hill" was sent along with Rimel's poem "Dreams of Yid", which appeared in The Fantasy Fan as "Dreams of Yith", with substantial Lovecraftian retouching. While the poem was picked up for reprinting by Arkham House (in Dark of the Moon), "The Tree on the Hill" sank into obscurity, having after all appeared in a rather obscure publication; Polaris was not even as widely read as The Fantasy Fan. Perhaps it would have been resurrected before now had anyone realized the extent of Lovecraft' s involvement in the tale. As Rimel himself now reflects, nearly fifty years later, Lovecraft wrote at least the whole of the last of the three sections, as well as the quoted passage from the text of elder lore. And as critical analysis to appear in Crypt of Cthulhu No. 17, "Revisions Issue II", will show, HPL may well have contributed more than this. At any rate, "The Tree on the Hill" supplies us with a meaty if small chunk of Lovecraftian fiction, as well as a welcome look at the creative skills of Duane W. Rimel, a fantasiste whose too-few works in the genre are valued by those who have read them.

"The Hand of Obeah" (i.e., of Voodoo) is a hitherto-unpublished "weird menace" yarn by Robert E. Howard. REH fans will readily note similarities to other minor Howard stories including "People of the Serpent", "Moon of Zambebwei", "Black Canaan", and "Black Talons". This story is far from Howard's best; indeed it is not even among the ranks of what one fan has dubbed "second-string Howard". It shares the faults of his other detective fiction, being chiefly notable perhaps as an attempt to create a character modeled upon Seabury Quinn's suave and silly occult investigator Jules de Grandin. At any rate, what Howard fan will not welcome the appearance of any "new" REH story?

"Double Cosmos" by Clark Ashton Smith is another work that has never before seen print. Readers of Smith's Black Book have seen an early synopsis of the tale as "The Appendix" (item 38). Smith had done some work on a draft of the story under the title "Secondary Cosmos" in late June, 1934. In a letter to R. H. Barlow, August 16, 1938, he reported that he was "trying to finish this". Another draft entitled "Double Cosmos" is dated February 24, 1940. The present version is undated but is the last version completed by Smith. The manuscript, incidentally, was partially burnt in a fire at Smith's cabin, but miraculously not a word of the story was lost!

"The Creeper in the Crypt" by Robert Bloch originally appeared in Weird Tales, the July 1937 issue. Thus, it is not quite the rarity that our first three tales are. Yet many of us are dependent on various paperback anthologies for our glimpses of vintage Weird Tales fiction. One such volume was Mysteries of the Worm (Zebra Books, 1981). Lin Carter edited this valuable collection of Robert Bloch's early Cthulhu Mythos fiction. Though Lovecraftian in nature, "The Creeper in the Crypt" was not included in Mysteries of the Worm. Those who having finished that book were still necrophagously hungry for more should enjoy this little episode in Arkham.

"Something from Out There" by August Derleth rounds out this booklet. It, too, is a Weird Tales reprint. Amazingly, given Derleth's penchant for collecting his multitudinous stories in book form, this one has never, to our knowledge, appeared in any collection. This is all the more astonishing since "Something from Out There" is a thorough-going Cthulhu Mythos story and is more original than most of Derleth's Mythos tales. In fact it is the third in a mini-series of stories featuring Derleth's grimoire The Confessions of the Mad Monk Clithanus. Brother Clithanus's tome first appeared in "The Passing of Eric Holme" (written under the house name "Will Garth") in Strange Stories, December 1939 (reprinted in Dwellers in Darkness, Arkham House, 1976). The Confessions surfaced again in Derleth and Schorer's "The Evil Ones" in Strange Stories, October 1940 (reprinted in Colonel Markesan and Less Pleasant People, Arkham House, 1966, as "The Horror from the Depths"). It's last appearance was in our story in Weird Tales, January 1951.

We would like to thank Duane Rimel, Gerry de la Ree, Scott Connors, S. T. Joshi, Glenn Lord, Steve Behrends, Mark Brown, Richard E. Kuhn, Charles Gray, Robert Bloch, Forrest O. Hartmann, and Steve Fabian for their indispensable help in this project.

Okay, wake up now, all you gibbering gore-mets, and feast all three of your eyes on these terrifying tidbits . . . heh, heh. . . .

Robert M. Price
The Old Crypt-of-Cthulhu-Keeper